Shame on Tory Chancellor dilute employees’ rights


George Osborne revived controversial plans to dilute employees’ rights by announcing that workers will be offered shares in their companies in return for giving up their legal rights at work.

From April next year, companies will be able to offer existing staff between £2,000 and £50,000 in tax-free shares if they surrender their rights to claim unfair dismissal, to redundancy pay, to request flexible working and time off for training. Women on maternity leave would have to give 16 weeks’ notice of returning to work, rather than eight weeks as at present. In return, these workers would not pay capital gains tax on any rise in the value of the shares when they sold them.

New firms could make such contracts compulsory. People working for existing firms could not be forced to sign them – but new recruits could be made to, under legislation to be rushed through Parliament. Workers who gave up their employment rights would not be able to change their minds and exercise them in future unless their employer agreed.

The Chancellor hopes that hundreds of thousands of workers will become “employee-owners”, mainly in fast-growing small- and medium-sized businesses which want a motivated and flexible workforce.

Mr Osborne’s plan is a variation of a proposal recommended to Downing Street by Adrian Beecroft, the venture capitalist and Conservative Party donor, whose idea of allowing firms to “fire at will” without fear of an unfair dismissal claim was blocked by the Liberal Democrats. But Nick Clegg’s party now supports the revised proposal because it is voluntary and advocates employee share ownership. Significantly, Mr Beecroft welcomed Mr Osborne’s announcement, saying: “This is a creative and exciting version of proposals that I made in my report. This is a significant step towards rebuilding Britain’s enterprise culture and is a real shot in the arm for Britain’s entrepreneurs.”


But unions accused the Government of implementing the shelved Beecroft report by the back door. Brendan Barber, General-Secretary of the Trades Union Congress, said: “We deplore any attack on maternity provision or protection against unfair dismissal.”


Paul Kenny, of the GMB union, added: “George Osborne, the man who is giving a £40,000 windfall to each of the millionaire elite, has announced more attacks on the least well-off in our society and on workers’ rights. Slashing people’s employment rights under the guise of ownership schemes won’t create jobs and it won’t create growth.”

Some business leaders warned that take-up of the scheme could be limited. Treasury sources admitted that big companies were unlikely to offer shares but estimated that the tax relief could cost £100m by 2017-18, based on between 50,000 and 75,000 “employee-owners” selling shares each year.

John Wright, an employment law expert, said: “You can’t agree to forgo your discrimination rights. If employees volunteer for this scheme, they could still take a case for race, age or sex discrimination.” He said he feared some people would feel coerced into volunteering for the conditions.

Mr Osborne unveiled his surprise move in his speech to Tory delegates in Birmingham. He also raised the prospect of further spending cuts on top of the £16bn he has pencilled in for 2015-16, saying “more hard choices” would have to be made this autumn.

There will be intense negotiations with the Liberal Democrats ahead of his autumn statement on 5 December, as the partners seek a trade-off between the £10bn of welfare cuts demanded by the Tories and the higher taxes on the rich sought by the Liberal Democrats. Mr Clegg is unlikely to back controversial cuts such as removing housing benefit from under-25s.

Mr Osborne ruled out the temporary wealth tax and the “mansion tax” on homes worth more than £2m proposed by Mr Clegg. Mr Osborne said that would amount to a “homes tax” and the Tories, as the party of home ownership, would “have no truck with it”.

The rights stuff: how it would work

Under the terms of the voluntary agreement, companies would be able to give employees shares in their business if, in return, they gave up a raft of employment rights. To encourage the scheme, no capital gains tax would be charged on any profit from the shares.

Employees would be given between £2,000 and £50,000 of shares, but would have to give up their rights to claiming unfair dismissal, redundancy, flexible working and time off for training. Women would also be required to provide 16 weeks’ notice of a date of return from maternity leave, instead of the current eight weeks.

Legislation to bring in the new-type contracts will come in later this year, with companies able to use them from April.

Just when you think that the Nasty Party gets our message to save our jobs and welfare no sooner Tory Chancellor George Osborne issued a chilling threat to the most vulnerable in society on Today by announcing billions more in welfare cuts.

Addressing the Tory Party conference in Birmingham the Chancellor said he intended to slash an extra £10 billion from benefits by 2016-2017, including proposals to limit the number of children per household that parents receive benefits for.

He told parents on benefits that they must make a “financial decision” about whether to have more children and said he was “questioning” whether parents should automatically get more cash if the size of their family increases.

He also said he would cut housing benefits for under-25s and claimed that they should live with their parents if they could not afford to live alone.

The overall message of his speech was a refusal to ease the austerity cuts.

“We will press on. We shall overcome,” he stated.

The coalition had made a promise to the British people, he said, that it would “repair the broken economy.”

“That promise is being fulfilled,” he claimed.

The Chancellor insisted the economy was “healing” but acknowledged it was taking longer than he had hoped.

“We will finish the job we started,” Mr Osborne declared.

“We are all in this together” was “more than just a slogan,” he said, it “spoke of our values and intent.

“Three years later the message remains the same.

“One nation working hard together. We are still all in this together.”

In a breathtakingly cynical move, he praised Adrian Beecroft for his employment legislation slashing proposals and then, in the next breath, brazenly declared: “Workers of the world unite!”

Mr Osborne denied that he was hammering the poor, claiming that there would be more taxes on the wealthy but, in a decision which will further anger the Tory’s coalition partners, he rejected out of hand the idea of a “mansion tax.”

The Chancellor said: “Just as we should never balance the budget on the backs of the poor, it’s an economic delusion to think you can balance it only on the wallets of the rich.”


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s